Medical Student Pearl
Julia Short
Med 2
DMNB Class of 2025
Reviewed by Dr D Lewis
Copy Edited by Dr. J Vonkeman
PDF Download: EMSJ Approach to Inguinal and Femoral Hernias in the ED by JShort
Case
A 52-year-old male patient presents in the ER with a lump in their right groin. The lump protrudes when they cough and when laying on their left side, although it re-enters the abdomen on its own. You wonder if it could be a femoral or an inguinal hernia, and how to go about differentiating between the two.
Introduction
A hernia is defined as an organ, or part of an organ, that protrudes through the body wall in which it is normally contained. The etiology of a hernia can be due to congenital anatomical malformations or from acquired weakening of the body wall tissues. There are various subtypes of abdominal hernias, while groin hernias consist of inguinal and femoral hernias. Throughout their lifetime, males have a 27 to 43% chance of developing a groin hernia, while females have a 3 to 6% lifetime prevalence1. Although it is much more likely that a groin hernia is inguinal in nature (they account for 96% of groin hernias), it is clinically useful to identify and distinguish between the types of groin hernias. Additionally, there are important clinical features that must not be overlooked when characterizing a groin hernia.
Distinguishing inguinal from femoral hernias
An important landmark in determining the hernia origin is the inguinal ligament. Inguinal hernias protrude superior to the inguinal ligament, while femoral hernias present inferior to the inguinal ligament (Figure 1). This is because femoral hernias protrude from the femoral ring, located medial to the femoral vein. As a result, in males, femoral hernias will never course into the scrotum. Femoral hernias also present more lateral than inguinal hernias and may be difficult to differentiate from lymph nodes. Although they account for only 3% of all groin hernias, 40% of femoral hernias present as urgent due to bowel strangulation or incarceration1. Females are more likely to develop femoral hernias, while males are more likely to develop inguinal hernias.
Figure 1. Groin anatomy © 2023 UpToDate7
Distinguishing between direct and indirect inguinal hernias
Direct inguinal hernias originate medially, near the pubic tubercle and external inguinal ring. They protrude through Hesselbach’s triangle as a result of weakness in the floor of the inguinal canal. On exam, a bulge near the external (superficial) inguinal ring is suggestive of a direct inguinal hernia. In contrast, indirect inguinal hernias protrude near the midpoint of the inguinal ligament, at the internal (deep) inguinal ring (Figure 2). In males and females respectively, the internal inguinal ring is where the spermatic cord and round ligament exit the abdomen. A bulge in this area therefore suggests an indirect inguinal hernia. This type of hernia is the most common in all ages and sexes, accounting for approximately two thirds of all inguinal hernias2. In males, the indirect hernia often courses into the scrotum, which can be palpated if the patient strains or coughs. In contrast, it is rare for a direct hernia to course into the scrotum.
Figure 2. Anatomical comparison of direct and indirect inguinal hernias © 2020 Dr. Vaibhav Kapoor8
Clinical Approach
General considerations for investigating groin hernias include assessing the symptoms at presentation as well as any “red flag” physical findings. Patients commonly complain of dull or heavy types of discomfort when straining, which resolves when straining stops. Most groin hernias occur on the right side. Common physical findings include a bulge in the groin, which can indicate the type of hernia based on location relative to the inguinal ligament (Figure 3). However, in female or obese patients, the layers of abdominal wall may make the hernia more difficult to locate. In these cases, ultrasound or other imaging is needed to detect hernias. Clinicians should also determine if the hernia is reducible, or if the herniated bowel can be returned to the abdominal cavity when moderate pressure is applied externally.
Figure 3. Locations of femoral and inguinal hernias on examination © 2023 UpToDate7
Physical examination has a 76 to 92% sensitivity and 96% specificity for diagnosing groin hernias, although imaging may also be required1,2. Nausea, vomiting, fever, moderate-to-severe abdominal pain, localized tenderness, or bloating may indicate more sinister pathology such as bowel incarceration (when the hernia contents cannot return to the abdominal cavity), strangulation (when the blood supply to the involved bowel section is compromised) or necrosis.
Figure 5. CT images of A) femoral hernia (courtesy of Chris O’Donnell9 and B) inguinal hernia (courtesy of Erik Ranschaert10)
Management
Uncomplicated or asymptomatic hernias in males can be monitored through watchful waiting. Surgical repair is a definitive treatment for inguinal hernias and should be considered for symptomatic or complex hernias. If repair is needed for an uncomplicated inguinal hernia, a laparoscopic repair is recommended. Watchful waiting is not recommended for femoral hernias – these patients should have a laparoscopic repair (when anatomically feasible).
Manual reduction of the hernia can be performed by following the GPS Taxis technique. Taxis is a non-invasive technique for manual reduction of incarcerated tissues in a hernia to the original compartment5. “GPS” is an acronym to remind clinicians to be gentle, be prepared, and be safe when performing taxis5. Conscious sedation with intravenous diazepam and morphine is recommended for the procedure. Consider having an anesthetist present for the procedure if the patient is frail. Provide appropriate early resuscitation by monitoring vital signs, administering oxygen therapy and establishing IV access. Place the patient in Trendelenburg position. Begin the GPS Taxis technique by palpating the fascial defect around the base of the hernia and gently manipulating hernia contents back into the abdominal cavity. Use gentle manipulation pressure over 5-10 minutes until a gurgling sound is heard (indicating successful reduction of bowel).
Taxis guided by ultrasound may increase success rates for reduction.
https://sjrhem.ca/taxis-reduction-of-inguinal-hernia/
Figure 4. Colourized clip demonstrating PoCUS assisted Taxis reduction of an inguinal hernia11
It should be noted that the major contraindication to performing GPS Taxis is bowel strangulation within the hernia. A rare but serious complication of manual reduction is reduction en masse, when a loop of bowel remains incarcerated at the neck of the hernia after manual reduction6. This can lead to early strangulation, intestinal necrosis, sepsis, organ failure and death. Femoral hernias and indirect inguinal hernias are at higher risk of reduction en masse from manual reduction attempts.
References:
- UpToDate – Classification, clinical features, and diagnosis of inguinal and femoral hernias in adults
- Hammoud M, Gerken J. Inguinal hernia. StatPearls. 2022 Aug 15.
- UpToDate – Overview of treatment for inguinal and femoral hernia in adults
- Bates’ Guide to Physical Examination and History Taking, 12th ed. (pdf). Chapter 13: Male Genitalia and Hernias
- Pawlak M, East B, de Beaux AC. Algorithm for management of an incarcerated inguinal hernia in the emergency settings with manual reduction. Taxis, the technique and its safety. Hernia, 25, 1253-1258. 2021 May 25.
- Yatawatta A. Reduction en masse of inguinal hernia: a review of a rare and potentially fatal complication following reduction of inguinal hernia. BMJ Case Rep. 2017 Aug 7.
- UpToDate – Classification, clinical features, and diagnosis of inguinal and femoral hernias in adults
- Kapoor, V. Difference between and inguinal and umbilical hernia. 2020. Retrieved from: https://www.drvaibhavkapoor.com/difference-between-inguinal-and-umbilical-hernia.html
- Patel, MS. Femoral hernia. Radiopaedia. 2022 Dec 28. Retrieved from: https://radiopaedia.org/articles/femoral-hernia
- Fahrenhorst-Jones, T. Inguinal hernia. Radiopaedia. 2022 Apr 12. Retrieved from: https://radiopaedia.org/articles/inguinal-hernia
- PoCUS assisted Taxis reduction of an inguinal hernia. Video obtained courtesy of Dr. David Lewis.